The Comparative Value of On-site vs Off-site Biodiversity Net Gain for Restoring Nature

by | Aug 4, 2025 | Uncategorised

The Comparative Value of On-site vs Off-site Biodiversity Net Gain for Restoring Nature

naturethrive works with farmers and landowners to implement Off-site BNG nature recovery projects and sells the uplift in nature to developers and frankly anyone who wants to make a meaningful and tangible investment into nature’s recovery into a legally bound site for the next 30 years. You also gets lots of lovely nature metrics to communicate the impact your investment is having on helping natures recovery and helping build more resilient businesses for farmers.

It is important to connect communities and employees on developments with nature and protect nature that is already on a site that is being built on – however there are many reasons why BNG could have a much more significant impact in solving the biodiversity crisis.

Here are some reasons why investing in offsite solutions could be a more viable option for developers:

Ecological Impact:

On-site BNG often results in fragmented, less effective nature uplift compared to the larger, expertly managed, and long-term funded and monitored off-site BNG sites. Bigger, better-connected sites mean more meaningful gains for nature’s recovery.

Cost Efficiency:

There is an assumption and in many cases emotive reaction to additional costs offsite – let’s cram it all onsite and reduce the costs – very understandable but note really the case as shown.

On-site BNG can significantly inflate housing costs, adding an estimated £12,000-£15,000 per house. In contrast, delivering BNG entirely off-site could reduce this to around £3,000 per house, making housing more affordable and development more viable.

Developer Challenges:

Developers face pressure to deliver BNG on-site, even when it reduces housing numbers and increases risk and costs.

I have heard many LPAs are stipulating onsite BNG even if it just doesn’t make sense and being very difficult around this – not really sure why..

Accountability:

Off-site BNG offers greater certainty through legal agreements and formal oversight, unlike on-site BNG, which often lacks consistent monitoring and enforcement.

This is super important – Responsible Bodies and LPAs regular audit and monitor progress for offsite nature recovery projects – they don’t have the resources to monitor onsite projects!

Market Potential:

Despite expectations, less than 10% of BNG is currently delivered off-site. Shifting this balance could unlock a thriving private market for nature, boost the UK’s leadership in nature finance, and accelerate our 2030 nature restoration targets.

You can find the full report and summary on the Foundation For Nature website here: https://www.foundationfornature.org/publications

Learn how you can make nature thrive